While preparing a review, an earlier meeting deck contains one target, a later discussion uses another baseline and the latest forecast contains a third figure. Each has a source. That does not make them interchangeable denominators for performance assessment.
The first task is to identify the role of each number. Arithmetic can be correct while the basis of comparison remains unresolved.
Keep different roles distinct
A target states an intended result. Actuals describe what has occurred. A forecast describes what current assumptions suggest may occur. A baseline still under discussion also needs a clear approval status.
These can appear together in one table if their labels remain explicit. The latest forecast should not be renamed a target, and an unapproved adjustment should not silently replace the historical reference.
Check the comparison fields
| Field | Question |
|---|---|
| Period and scope | Full year, part year or a particular business scope? |
| Unit and basis | Are quantities, amounts or milestone attribution consistent? |
| Revision and status | When was the source updated, and is it proposed or approved? |
| Role of the figure | Target, actual, forecast or scenario? |
| Decision basis | Which version applies to this review, confirmed by whom? |
Adding actuals for one period to forecasts for another still produces a total with forecast conditions. A single combined figure does not turn the unfulfilled portion into an actual result.
Bring unresolved versions into the meeting
We have retained the historical target, later proposed baseline and latest forecast. Please confirm which version and period apply to this assessment. Forecast assumptions will remain separate from actual records.
Different targets can lead to different assessments of the same result. Making the version question explicit keeps the discussion focused on evidence instead of an ambiguous achievement percentage.
A training exercise can provide several entirely fictional versions. Before asking for a calculation, ask a colleague to identify what each figure represents and whose confirmation is still needed. Recognising an unresolved basis is more useful than quickly producing a percentage that nobody agreed to use.
Related: Emails sent, meetings held—what changed in the project?.
Drawn from questions raised in a periodic work review. Identities, business figures and project details have been removed. Checklists and sample wording are for similar situations; they do not establish a completed outcome.