A customer describes a function and an existing product immediately comes to mind. Its dimensions look close, and the photographs seem suitable. It is tempting to send the product information straight away.

But “we have something similar” and “this performs the requested action” are different statements. This kind of enquiry reminds me to verify the use case before treating a recommendation as a fit. Offering an option is not evidence that it has been validated.

Describe a function that someone can demonstrate

Who uses the pack, in what condition, to perform which action, and with what intended result? Ask the customer to confirm that sentence before focusing on appearance or dimensions. “Easy to use” could mean opening, dispensing, refilling or carrying; the supplier should not silently choose the meaning.

If the operating conditions are missing, ask for them rather than choosing the closest product name in the catalogue.

Build a small fit table

Required action or conditionExisting option providesCurrent assessmentNext action
Confirmed requirementRelevant function or limitationMeets / needs validation / does not meetDemonstration, test or engineering review

“Needs validation” is a useful state. It should not become “meets” simply to make the proposal more attractive. Where adaptation is required, ask engineering to assess the gap and identify what the proposed sample can establish.

Explain gaps before quoting

If the existing option meets only part of the need, discuss alternatives: retain it with an accepted limitation, assess an adaptation, or define a new development scope. Show the unresolved conditions for each route. Do not conceal development work within the description “existing product.”

Please confirm the use action you need so we can check our understanding. We will distinguish the supported features from those requiring validation. Once the gap is clear, we can agree the sample arrangement and commercial conditions.

A useful training exercise pairs a fictional requirement with a similar-looking product that lacks one critical function. Ask the colleague to explain the gap before recommending it. Giving the customer a clear basis for judgment is more valuable than sending a fast but ambiguous suggestion.

Related: A new pack: adapt an existing platform or develop from scratch?.


Reflections and working methods drawn from work records. Identifying and commercial details have been removed. Suggested actions do not imply a completed outcome; decisions still require the responsible people’s confirmation.